Emergency Movie Review: Kangana Ranaut’s Ambitious Indira Gandhi Biopic Falls Short

JB Expert

Updated on:

Emergency Movie Review: Kangana Ranaut’s Ambitious Indira Gandhi Biopic Falls Short

Kangana Ranaut’s Emergency attempts to unravel the life of one of India’s most complex leaders, Indira Gandhi, amidst one of the country’s darkest political chapters. However, while the film aims for grandeur and gravitas, it struggles under the weight of its ambition, faltering in execution and narrative depth.

Video


Introduction to Emergency

Released amidst much anticipation and controversy, Emergency is a historical drama written, directed, and led by Kangana Ranaut. The film seeks to portray the transformative years of Indira Gandhi, particularly during the Emergency period (1975–1977). With a promising premise and a narrative that intertwines personal and political dynamics, the movie seemed poised to offer a gripping retelling of history. Unfortunately, it falls victim to inconsistent storytelling and underwhelming craftsmanship.


Plot Summary

The story chronicles Indira Gandhi’s journey from being a determined young woman to an authoritarian leader. It delves into her strained relationships, political battles, and her eventual redemption. The Emergency, a critical juncture in Indian history, takes center stage but feels underexplored. The narrative frequently oscillates between historical events, family drama, and Gandhi’s introspections, failing to provide a cohesive storyline.


Direction and Screenplay: A Missed Opportunity

Kangana Ranaut’s directorial vision for Emergency is ambitious, yet her execution lacks finesse. The screenplay, though brimming with potential, suffers from uneven pacing and excessive exposition. Historical events are rushed, and the emotional arcs of characters feel superficial.

Weak Points in Screenwriting:

  1. Overemphasis on Indira Gandhi’s Persona: The film spends an inordinate amount of time portraying her as a misunderstood figure rather than a nuanced leader.
  2. Shallow Depiction of Historical Figures: Iconic personalities like Jayaprakash Narayan and George Fernandes are reduced to brief, almost forgettable roles.
  3. Overloaded Narrative: Instead of focusing on the Emergency, the film tries to cover too many events, leaving significant moments underexplored.

Strengths in Direction:

Ranaut’s attention to period details—such as costumes, sets, and prosthetics—deserves commendation. The prosthetic nose and Gandhi’s trademark white streak of hair are visually striking, contributing to the film’s authenticity.


Acting Performances: A Mixed Bag

Emergency Movie Review: Kangana Ranaut’s Ambitious Indira Gandhi Biopic Falls Short

Kangana Ranaut as Indira Gandhi

Ranaut’s portrayal of Indira Gandhi is competent but inconsistent. While she captures Gandhi’s steely demeanor, her exaggerated mannerisms—pursed lips and a contrived accent—distract from an otherwise earnest performance. Despite these flaws, Ranaut manages to evoke the inner turmoil of a leader caught between personal vulnerabilities and political machinations.

Notable Supporting Performances

  • Milind Soman as Field Marshal Manekshaw: His performance lacks depth and fails to capture the gravitas of the real-life figure.
  • Vishak Nair as Sanjay Gandhi: Nair’s portrayal of the reckless and manipulative son is one of the film’s stronger elements, though it sometimes borders on caricature.
  • Shreyas Talpade as Atal Bihari Vajpayee: Talpade delivers a surprisingly impactful performance, adding subtle dignity to his limited screen time.
  • Anupam Kher as Jayaprakash Narayan: Despite his talent, Kher’s role feels underwritten, giving him little room to shine.

Cinematography and Production Design

The visual appeal of Emergency is a mixed affair. While the production design captures the essence of 1970s India, the cinematography is lackluster.

Key Highlights:

  1. Costumes and Styling: The handloom saris and period-accurate attire are commendable, enhancing the film’s historical authenticity.
  2. Set Design: Iconic locations like the Parliament House and Indira’s residence are recreated with care.
  3. Flaws in Cinematography: Overuse of close-ups and poorly executed CGI sequences diminish the film’s visual impact.

Music and Sound Design

The background score attempts to underscore the gravity of the events but often feels melodramatic. The decision to include a bizarre musical sequence involving political figures is baffling, detracting from the film’s seriousness.

  • Best Use of Music: The somber score during Indira’s introspective moments works well.
  • Worst Use of Music: The Parliament song sequence undermines the film’s tone and credibility.

Historical Representation: Fact or Fiction?

Emergency treads a precarious line between historical drama and fictionalized narrative. While it claims to be based on verified sources, the film often distorts events to suit its agenda.

  • Bias in Storytelling: The film glorifies Indira Gandhi’s leadership while deflecting blame for controversial actions onto others, such as Sanjay Gandhi.
  • Missed Opportunities: Critical moments like the infamous sterilization campaign and press censorship are either glossed over or ignored.

Comparison with Similar Films

Film Strengths Weaknesses
Emergency Strong lead performance, authentic styling Weak screenplay, superficial characters
Veer Savarkar Compelling narrative, tight direction Lesser-known subject limits audience
The Accidental Prime Minister Focused storytelling, balanced portrayal Limited cinematic appeal

Audience Reception

Demographic Appeal

  • Young Audiences: May struggle to connect with the historical context.
  • Older Viewers: Likely to appreciate the effort but may find inaccuracies frustrating.

Global Reception

While Ranaut’s performance garners praise internationally, critics highlight the film’s weak storytelling and lack of nuance.


Strengths and Weaknesses

Strengths:

  1. Kangana Ranaut’s commitment to the role.
  2. Period-accurate costumes and set design.
  3. Ambitious attempt to tackle a complex historical figure.

Weaknesses:

  1. Inconsistent screenplay.
  2. Distracting mannerisms in lead performance.
  3. Oversimplified and biased portrayal of historical events.
  4. Poor CGI and overuse of melodrama.

Conclusion: A Flawed Political Saga

Emergency had the potential to be a groundbreaking political drama, but it succumbs to weak storytelling and uneven execution. While Kangana Ranaut’s performance is commendable, the film’s lack of focus and historical depth undermines its impact. For viewers seeking a balanced and insightful portrayal of Indira Gandhi, Emergency is more a missed opportunity than a must-watch.


Discussion Prompt

What are your thoughts on the portrayal of Indira Gandhi in Emergency? How do you think Bollywood should approach historical dramas in the future? Let us know in the comments below!


Call to Action

If you’re interested in political dramas, consider watching The Accidental Prime Minister or revisiting classics like Gandhi. Don’t forget to share your thoughts and subscribe for more in-depth movie reviews!

Read More Movie Reviews HERE

Leave a comment